The World According to Renee

Views, Reviews, Short Stories and More…

Musings: Caroline Overington novels

Recently I read Matilda is Missing, a novel by Caroline Overington. I’ve also previously read I Came to Say Goodbye and I’ve just started Ghost Child. In the Reader’s Group questions for Matilda is Missing, it is asked why Barry is chosen as the narrator to tell Matilda’s story when he has nothing to do with the family or the case? It’s not only this novel which employs this particular form of narrative, Ms Overington’s other novels do the same; have other people tell the story.

I have my own theory about this. Ms Overington is a journalist. Journalists are supposed to remain disassociated from their subjects and present a broad and unbiased view. Perhaps this is the reason she chooses unrelated characters to narrate? In both I Came to Say Goodbye and Matilda is Missing, the story is told through the eyes of men in their 60s who are only vaguely related to the narrative they tell. Ghost Child is different; the narrative is presented through the eyes of several characters, none of whom are central to the story. It’s an interesting device because it keeps the story in perspective by allowing each character their own versions of the story. We all know the old adage There’s three sides to every story: your side, my side and the Truth. This novel really presents itself as showing a 3D view of the central story; a child has died. The narrators range from the sister of the child to a police officer on the scene, foster carer, doctor and others not directly related to the family. In this way, a broad view is formed of the central plot and each character brings their own bias, so the reader is left to decipher The Truth.

Using unrelated characters to tell another’s story also allows the reader to make their own judgments. I wrote earlier about The Sense of An Ending which leaves the reader wondering if the narrative is actually correct or if the novel is a game to trick the mind. The novels of Caroline Overington could be construed in the same way- is the plot being read what is actually happening or could it be the narrator is messing with our minds to garner sympathy for their plight?

The best way, in my opinion, to view these novels is to remember the journalism beginnings of the author. She’s used to writing from a perspective not of the subject but someone witnessing the event/s and reporting as a bystander. Either this habit is hard to break, or serves the purpose of continuing to present a different opinion from someone unrelated. Either way, I like the style of writing as it adds depth and a ‘humanness’ to the narrative.

When speaking of Caroline Overington’s novels, I also have to mention the names chosen for characters. Years ago, I read a How-To guide for writers. One of the Things You Must Never Do was to create characters with similar names, yet Ms Overington does this a lot. For example, Matilda is Missing has characters named Pat Harrison and Pam Harris, Garry and Barry. Ghost Child  has two children named Harley and Hayley. Now, while the reader isn’t confused by these characters (unless they are reading while very tired), it strikes me as odd. When asked via Twitter why this naming was important, Ms Overington replied, “Don’t you find life is like that sometimes?” Well, no, not in my experience. Giving similar names to characters can confuse the reader as well as look for hidden meaning and coincidences that simply aren’t there or require no thought- they just are. There’s nothing necessarily wrong with it; Stephen King often has the same name for different people in different novels. Maybe having similar names is a common thread between people who have no other similarities yet find themselves intertwined through no fault or cause of their own?

In any case, these novels are inherently about humans and the complexities of The System in which we live and operate under. Life can’t always be planned and Ms Overington’s novels show Aussies as we really are, warts and all. In the end, we’re all in the same boat.


November 14, 2011 - Posted by | Thoughts & Reflections

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: